Submit a Claim

Most of the time, it is best to report your claim directly to our agency. We work hard to maintain a relationship with each of our clients and will have extra information and advice to help guide you through the settlement of the claim. To report a claim right now, you can contact us directly.

Call Capitol at (317) 253.1155

If our offices are closed and you need to submit your claim immediately, your insurance company may allow you to report your claim directly by using the contact information below.

Company Phone Website
American Modern Home (800) 543.2644 Visit
Auto Owners Insurance Co (800) 288.8740 Visit
Citizens Insurance (888) 685.1555 Visit
First Comp / Markel Insurance (888) 500.3344 Visit
Hanover Insurance Group (800) 573.1187 Visit
Hartford Insurance Group (860) 547.5000 Visit
Mennonite Mutual (800) 678.6885 Visit
Motorists Insurance Companies (800) 876.6642 Visit
NSI-Division of West Bend (800) 236.5010 Visit
Philadelphia Insurance Company (877) 438.7459 Visit
Progressive Insurance Company (855) 758.0943 Visit
Safeco Insurance (800) 332.3226 Visit
Travelers Insurance Company (800) 842.5075 Visit