Payments

Most insurance companies allow you to pay your insurance payments on their website or over the phone by credit card or by electronic check. Below is information on how to make payments to your insurance company. If you have any problems, please contact Capitol Insurance during office hours at (317) 253.1155 or (800) 305.9856.

CompanyPhoneWebsite
American Modern Home (800) 543.2644 Visit
Auto Owners Insurance Co (800) 288.8740 Visit
Citizens Insurance (888) 685.1555 Visit
First Comp / Markel Insurance (888) 500.3344 Visit
Hanover Insurance Group (800) 573.1187 Visit
Hartford Insurance Group (860) 547.5000 Visit
Mennonite Mutual (800) 678.6885 Visit
Motorists Insurance Companies (800) 876.6642 Visit
NSI-Division of West Bend (800) 236.5010 Visit
Philadelphia Insurance Company (877) 438.7459 Visit
Progressive Insurance Company (855) 758.0943 Visit
Travelers Insurance Company (800) 842.5075 Visit